What The Hell America!

The Trump administration has threatened to withhold federal funds from public schools that have diversity, equity and inclusion programs.

In a letter to state leaders across the country, the U.S. Education Department said Title I funding, which is targeted to schools with a high proportion of low income students, would be threatened if schools failed to follow its interpretation of civil rights laws.

Any violation of civil rights law, it says, “including the use of Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion (‘DEI’) programs to advantage one’s race over another—is impermissible.”

School and state officials are required to sign a certification letter attached to the memo and return it to the department within 10 days, proving that they are complying with the directive.

This is the latest in a series of letters the department has issued to state and local school leaders: one focused on student privacy, another abruptly ending COVID relief funding promised to schools, and another issuing guidance on how to use federal funds to support parent choice in public education.

While Secretary of Education Linda McMahon has not clearly defined what the administration considers a violation of civil rights law, the agency issued a letter in February that notified educational institutions that they must “cease using race preferences and stereotypes as a factor in their admissions, hiring, promotion, scholarship.”

In a related document addressing frequently asked questions about how the administration would interpret Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the agency said: “Many schools have advanced discriminatory policies and practices under the banner of ‘DEI’ initiatives.” The document went on to say that schools could engage in historical observances like Black History Month “so long as they do not engage in racial exclusion or discrimination.”

While the federal government is only responsible for about 10% of money that goes to schools, Title I is one of the largest federal grants overseen by the Education Department: In the current fiscal year, the federal government set aside more than $18.38 billion for Title I. Nearly 90% of U.S. school districts benefit from the program.

“Federal financial assistance is a privilege, not a right,” Craig Trainor, the department’s acting assistant secretary for civil rights, said in a statement. “When state education commissioners accept federal funds, they agree to abide by federal antidiscrimination requirements. Unfortunately, we have seen too many schools flout or outright violate these obligations, including by using DEI programs to discriminate against one group of Americans to favor another based on identity characteristics.”

Many educators worry that the removal of this money could have significant impacts, especially to rural and low income communities that rely heavily on federal funding. In response to the February guidance from the department, education groups, including the American Federation of Teachers, are suing to block the Department of Education from enforcing its recent civil rights guidance.

In the rural Lucerne Valley Unified School District in the high desert of California, Superintendent Peter Livingston says he’s still digesting the latest news of threats to Title I funding.

He explains that 90% of his district’s students are considered economically disadvantaged, and all of its schools rely on Title I.

“If the money were to be threatened, that would have a huge impact,” he says.

But he also favors the efforts to reduce the role of the Education Department in local schools, especially if it means federal dollars could be used more efficiently.

He says his district uses Title I funds to hire staff, to keep class sizes smaller and for academic programs that help “level the playing field” for students regardless of their income.

“If the regulations are in place that we have to follow,” he adds, “that’s what we’d be doing in order to ensure that we had the money to serve our students.”